Stella and Chewy’s Cat Food Review

Stella and Chewys cat food logo

About Stella and Chewy’s

The story of Stella and Chewy’s began when Marie Moody adopted a dog named Stella from a local animal shelter in 1997. She wanted Stella to have a friend, so shortly after she adopted a sick puppy named Chewy. In order to support Chewy’s health, Marie consulted a veterinarian and began to feed him a raw diet as a result. Chewy quickly recovered and Stella also thrived on a raw diet; then the idea for her company was planted. 

Marie turned this realization and experience into Stella and Chewy’s in 2003. Just out of her small kitchen in her 600 square foot, one-bedroom apartment in Brooklyn, New York, Marie continued her passion for pet nutrition and the raw food was a hit in the neighborhood and word caught on. Nowadays, the company has been producing food in a much larger kitchen—its main facility in Oak Creek, Wisconsin. 

Since its creation, Stella and Chewy’s has operated under the belief that most pets are most likely to thrive when they are fed the same diet as they are in the wild. That’s why they use the highest quality raw ingredients to ensure complete and balanced nutrition.

All of their pet food products are made in FDA-inspected plants in the Milwaukee, Wisconsin area. They work closely with a small, select group of suppliers to ensure the quality and safety of their ingredients and production process. 

While many traditional kibbles are made using an extrusion process, Stella and Chewy’s patented food safety process known as SecureByNature® involves high-pressure processing, which is a low-temperature process that leaves the food’s color, texture, flavor, and nutrient value intact while destroying pathogenic organisms.

Beyond its commitment to nutrition, the company is also dedicated to animal welfare and doing its part to support local shelters and rescues. 

Now that you have more background on Stella and Chewy’s, it’s time to dive deeper into their cat food. To help you better decide on whether their products are the right fit for your feline, we’ve reviewed their highest rated cat food below.

 

Best Dry Cat Food

from Stella and Chewy’s

Stella & Chewy’s Chick Chick Chicken Dinner Morsels Freeze-Dried Raw Cat Food

What we like
  • Contains 98% protein made from real animal meat, organ and bones

  • Fortified with taurine and probiotics for dietary health

  • The benefits of raw food with the convenience of dry food

  • Made to mimic a cat’s natural diet in the wild

  • No grains, gluten, fillers or artificial flavors or preservatives

  • 100% complete and balanced recipe for all life stages

Things to consider
  • The pellets tend to be too large for some cats

  • On the pricier side

Check the price on Amazon
Check the price on Chewy

For an all-natural recipe your cat will be clawing over, go with Stella & Chewy’s natural freeze-dried food. This is a high-quality, affordable diet and potentially one of the best value picks for what you get – sustainably sourced ingredients, raw protein, and essential vitamins for your cat’s health. As such, it is made to build and maintain strong muscles for your cat. Then it’s all made to be freeze-fried, providing your feline friend with real and raw nutrition. 

This food is made to closely mimic a cat’s natural diet in the wild: high in protein and low carbohydrates. For this reason, the product’s recipe is 98% of poultry meat, organ, and bone. So it’s not only rich in animal protein but contains no grains or gluten. Additional nutrients include taurine, probiotics, antioxidants, and Vitamins A and E. 

The morsels are freeze-dried and the limited ingredient recipe is made in small batches right here in the USA. It’s the perfect choice if you want convenience, something that tastes good, and if you’re trying to transition your kitty to a high-moisture diet. You can easily feed it as is (raw) or slowly rehydrate it by adding cool or warm (never hot) water. 

Overall, this is a simple, holistic recipe with limited ingredients. It’s important to note that pet parents and vets claim raw food to have a positive effect on appetite, digestion, immune system, teeth health, and skin and coat health. 

Stella and Chewy’s Chick Chick Chicken Dinner Morsels Freeze-Dried Raw Cat Food contains 182 calories per cup.

Ingredients:

Chicken (ground with bone), Chicken Liver, Chicken Gizzard, Pumpkin Seed, Potassium Chloride, Sodium Phosphate, Choline Chloride, Dried Pediococcus acidilactici Fermentation Product, Dried Lactobacillus acidophilus Fermentation Product, Dried Bifidobacterium longum Fermentation Product, Dried Bacilius coagulans Fermentation Product, Taurine, Tocopherols (Preservative), Dandelion, Dried Kelp, Zinc Proteinate, Iron Proteinate, Vitamin E Supplement, Niacin Supplement, Copper Proteinate, Riboflavin Supplement, Sodium Selenite, D-Calcium Pantothenate, Biotin, Man;ganese Proteinate, Thiamine Mononitrate, Pyridoxine Hydrochloride, Vitamin D3 Supplement, Folic Acid, Vitamin B12 Supplement.

Check out the complete list of best dry cat food

How does Stella and Chewy’s stack up as a brand – Nutritional Comparisons

Stella and Chewy’s DRY Food

Stella and Chewy’s Dry Food (avg)

Industry Average

Protein

42.6

34

Fat

26.7

14

Fibre

5.0

4.5

Avg Review ( /5)

4.1

4.3

Brand Recalls

Stella & Chewy’s was recalled twice in 2015 due to potential listeria contamination of a variety of frozen and freeze-dried products.

Where to buy Stella and Chewy’s Online

Amazon
Chewy

Best Dry Cat Food from Crave

The Daily Cat Ratings

We have analyzed 102 of Blue Buffalo cat food products on Chewy. We took into account ingredient quality, guaranteed analysis, price, product variety, customer experience, and recall history. All of these factors combined produced an overall brand score, ratings for their wet and dry food lines (maybe), as well as individual product ratings.

We give Blue Buffalo Cat Food a 6.75/10 rating and a C+ grade.

Blue Buffalo Cat Food Ratings:

  • Ingredient Quality: 6/10

  • Guaranteed Analysis: 6/10
  • Price: 8.5/10
  • Product variety: 9/10
  • Customer reviews: 7/10
  • Recall history: 4/10
  • DailyCat Score: 6.75/10

Top Blue Buffalo products

Blue Buffalo Wilderness High Protein Natural Adult Dry Cat Food

Blue Buffalo Wilderness High Protein, Natural Adult Dry Cat Food
  • Dry food

  • Price per 100 calories: $0.18

  • Best for: Adult cats

  • Overall grade: B

Check Price

Blue Buffalo Indoor Health Natural Adult Dry Cat Food

Blue Buffalo Indoor Health Natural Adult Dry Cat Food
  • Dry food

  • Price per 100 calories: $0.15

  • Best for: Indoor cats

  • Overall grade: C

Check Price

Blue Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Natural Adult Flaked Wet Cat Food

Blue Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Natural Adult Flaked Wet Cat Food
  • Wet food

  • Price per 100 calories: $1.36

  • Best for: Cats of all life stages

  • Overall grade: B-

Check Price

Complete List of Nutro Dry Cat Food

Nutro Grain-Free Chicken & Potato Recipe Adult Dry Cat Food, 3-lb bag
Protein Fat Fibre
33 16 4
Read more
Nutro Wholesome Essentials Sensitive Cat Chicken, Rice & Peas Recipe Dry Cat Food, 5-lb bag Nutro Wholesome Essentials Sensitive Cat Chicken, Rice & Peas Recipe Dry Cat Food, 5-lb bag
Protein Fat Fibre
33 16 4
Read more
Nutro Wholesome Essentials Adult Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Cat Food, 5-lb bag Nutro Wholesome Essentials Adult Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Cat Food, 5-lb bag
Protein Fat Fibre
33 16 4
Read more
Nutro Wholesome Essentials Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Senior Dry Cat Food, 14-lb bag Nutro Wholesome Essentials Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Senior Dry Cat Food, 14-lb bag
Protein Fat Fibre
36 17 6
Read more
Nutro Wholesome Essentials Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Kitten Dry Cat Food, 5-lb bag Nutro Wholesome Essentials Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Kitten Dry Cat Food, 5-lb bag
Protein Fat Fibre
36 19 4
Read more
Nutro Wholesome Essentials Hairball Control Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Adult Dry Cat Food, 14-lb bag
Protein Fat Fibre
33 17 6.5
Read more
Nutro Wholesome Essentials Adult Salmon & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Cat Food, 14-lb bag Nutro Wholesome Essentials Adult Salmon & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Cat Food, 14-lb bag
Protein Fat Fibre
33 16 4
Read more
Nutro Wholesome Essentials Indoor Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Adult Dry Cat Food, 14-lb bag Nutro Wholesome Essentials Indoor Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Adult Dry Cat Food, 14-lb bag
Protein Fat Fibre
33 14 7
Read more

Complete List of Nutro Dry Cat Food

Nutro Grain-Free Chicken & Potato Recipe Adult Dry Cat Food, 3-lb bag
Protein Fat Fibre
33 16 4
Read more
Nutro Wholesome Essentials Sensitive Cat Chicken, Rice & Peas Recipe Dry Cat Food, 5-lb bag Nutro Wholesome Essentials Sensitive Cat Chicken, Rice & Peas Recipe Dry Cat Food, 5-lb bag
Protein Fat Fibre
33 16 4
Read more
Nutro Wholesome Essentials Adult Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Cat Food, 5-lb bag Nutro Wholesome Essentials Adult Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Cat Food, 5-lb bag
Protein Fat Fibre
33 16 4
Read more
Nutro Wholesome Essentials Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Senior Dry Cat Food, 14-lb bag Nutro Wholesome Essentials Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Senior Dry Cat Food, 14-lb bag
Protein Fat Fibre
36 17 6
Read more
Nutro Wholesome Essentials Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Kitten Dry Cat Food, 5-lb bag Nutro Wholesome Essentials Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Kitten Dry Cat Food, 5-lb bag
Protein Fat Fibre
36 19 4
Read more
Nutro Wholesome Essentials Hairball Control Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Adult Dry Cat Food, 14-lb bag
Protein Fat Fibre
33 17 6.5
Read more
Nutro Wholesome Essentials Adult Salmon & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Cat Food, 14-lb bag Nutro Wholesome Essentials Adult Salmon & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Cat Food, 14-lb bag
Protein Fat Fibre
33 16 4
Read more
Nutro Wholesome Essentials Indoor Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Adult Dry Cat Food, 14-lb bag Nutro Wholesome Essentials Indoor Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Adult Dry Cat Food, 14-lb bag
Protein Fat Fibre
33 14 7
Read more

Complete list of Nutro Wet Cat food

Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Chicken Paté Recipe Cat Food Trays, 2.6-oz, case of 24 twin-packs Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Chicken Paté Recipe Cat Food Trays, 2.6-oz, case of 24 twin-packs
Protein Fat Fibre
12 5 1
Read more
Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Salmon & Chicken Paté Recipe Cat Food Trays, 2.6-oz, case of 24 Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Salmon & Chicken Paté Recipe Cat Food Trays, 2.6-oz, case of 24
Protein Fat Fibre
12 5 1
Read more
Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Chicken & Liver Paté Recipe Cat Food Trays, 2.6-oz, case of 24 Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Chicken & Liver Paté Recipe Cat Food Trays, 2.6-oz, case of 24
Protein Fat Fibre
11.5 6 1
Read more
Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Cuts in Gravy Salmon Recipe Cat Food Trays, 2.65-oz, case of 24 twin-packs Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Cuts in Gravy Salmon Recipe Cat Food Trays, 2.65-oz, case of 24 twin-packs
Protein Fat Fibre
9 4 1
Read more
Nutro-Perfect-Portions-Grain-Free-Chicken-Liver-&-Shrimp-Paté-Recipe-Cat-Food-Trays,-2.6-oz,-case-of-24 Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Chicken Liver & Shrimp Paté Recipe Cat Food Trays, 2.6-oz, case of 24
Protein Fat Fibre
12 5 1
Read more
Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Cuts in Gravy Beef Recipe Cat Food Trays, 2.65-oz, case of 24 twin-packs Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Cuts in Gravy Beef Recipe Cat Food Trays, 2.65-oz, case of 24 twin-packs
Protein Fat Fibre
8.5 5 1
Read more
Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Cuts in Gravy Beef Recipe Cat Food Trays, 2.65-oz, case of 24 twin-packs Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Cuts in Gravy Beef Recipe Cat Food Trays, 2.65-oz, case of 24 twin-packs
Protein Fat Fibre
8.5 5 1
Read more
Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Paté Multi-Pack Real Salmon & Tuna, Real Chicken & Shrimp Recipe Cat Food Trays, 2.65-oz, case of 12 twin-packs Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Paté Multi-Pack Real Salmon & Tuna, Real Chicken & Shrimp Recipe Cat Food Trays, 2.65-oz, case of 12 twin-packs
Protein Fat Fibre
12 5 1
Read more
Products Protein Fat Fibre
Nutro Wild Frontier Real Chicken & Beef, Real Salmon & Trout Recipe Pate Multipack Adult High-Protein Grain-Free Cat Food Trays, 2.65-oz, case of 12 twin-packs 12.5 6.5 1
Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Cuts in Gravy Chicken & Catfish Recipe Adult Cat Food Trays, 2.64-oz, case of 24 twin-packs 8.5 5 1
Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Cuts in Gravy Chicken & Salmon Recipe Cat Food Trays, 2.65-oz, case of 24 twin-packs 8.5 5 1
Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Turkey & Liver Paté Recipe Cat Food Trays, 2.6-oz, case of 24 11.5 7 1
Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Cuts in Gravy Turkey Recipe Cat Food Trays, 2.65-oz, case of 24 twin-packs 9 6 1
Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Cuts in Gravy Tuna Recipe Cat Food Trays, 2.65-oz, case of 24 twin-packs 8.5 5 1
Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Chicken & Shrimp Paté Recipe Cat Food Trays, 2.6-oz, case of 24 twin-packs 12 5 1
Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Turkey Paté Recipe Cat Food Trays, 2.6-oz, case of 24 twin-packs 12 5 1
Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Beef Paté Recipe Adult Cat Food Trays, 2.64-oz, case of 24 twin-packs 12.5 7 1
Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Cuts in Gravy Chicken Recipe Cat Food Trays, 2.65-oz, case of 24 twin-packs 8.5 5 1
Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Cuts in Gravy Variety Pack Chicken & Beef Recipe Adult Cat Food Trays, 2.64-oz, case of 12 twin-packs 8.5 5 1
Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Variety Pack Chicken, Salmon & Tuna, Chicken & Liver Paté Recipe Adult Cat Food Trays, 2.64-oz, case of 24 twin-packs 12 5 1
Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Salmon & Tuna Paté Recipe Cat Food Trays, 2.6-oz, case of 24 twin-packs 12 5 1
Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Cuts in Gravy Variety Pack Beef, Tuna & Chicken Recipe Adult Cat Food Trays, 2.64-oz, case of 24 twin-packs 8.5 5 1
Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Multi-Pack Real Turkey & Real Chicken Paté Recipe Cat Food Trays, 2.65-oz, case of 12 twin-packs 8.5 5 1
Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Multi-Pack Real Turkey & Real Chicken Cuts in Gravy Recipe Cat Food Trays, 2.65-oz, case of 12 twin-packs 8.5 5 1